If my car is repossessed, do I still owe money?
ResourcesRisk & Safety

If my car is repossessed, do I still owe money?

The repo doesn't always wipe the slate clean. Learn about deficiency balances.

By Sarah Jenkins
December 18, 2025
4 min read

Disclaimer: Idaho Title Loans is an informational resource and referral service, not a direct lender. We do not make credit decisions. All loan terms, interest rates, and conditions are determined solely by the third-party lender you are connected with. Availability of funds and approval are not guaranteed. Please borrow responsibly.

Many borrowers assume, "Well, they took my car, so we're even." Unfortunately, that's not always true. You can lose your car and still owe money.

The Auction Process

When a lender takes your car, they sell it at a wholesale auction. These auctions rarely bring top dollar.

  • Loan Balance: $5,000
  • Repo Fees & Storage: +$500
  • Total Debt: $5,500

If the car only sells for $4,000 at auction, there is a shortfall of $1,500.

The Deficiency Balance

That $1,500 difference is called a "deficiency balance." In many jurisdictions, the lender can sue you for this amount. They can garnish wages or levy bank accounts to collect it.

The Surplus: Conversely, if the car sells for $7,000, they must pay you the extra $1,500 (surplus). They cannot keep the profit. If your car is repossessed, ensure you demand a record of the sale price.


S

Sarah Jenkins

Financial Editor

Sarah is a financial expert with over 10 years of experience in consumer lending. She is dedicated to transparency in the lending market.